Holmes explains that that is how he solves mysteries so adeptly. Batman could study a lot of history, but he spends most of his time in the mordern world. - Sherlock deduces much of Batman's origins simply by looking at him. He's a strategist and tactician, he should know what to do in a situation like this! The Caped Crusader, Batman, dukes it out with the master detective Sherlock Holmes and his accomplice, Dr. Watson, in order to see who is the greater crime fighter. The most obvious reason would bethere are many ways that proves Sherlock will never win against batman in an Investigation Showdown. The most obvious reason would beThis is in Holmes era.Batman is at the disadvantage in this oneIm fully aware of what Batman is capable (Im actually a fanboy of him as well)Id ask you read the OP.It states that Batman is in London,the year is 1890.Batman has no gear except a magnifying glass.As great a detective as Bruce is he is way out of his element here.This is a city for all intense and purposes he has never been to where he knows absolutely no one.Getting into the crime scene is going to be a task by itself.Who would let him in?Not the police.They have no idea who this guy is.On top of that he has very little way of gathering information at all.Hes going to stick out like a sore thumb so speaking to anyone is pretty much out of the question.Even if he beats the answers out of them how will he know who to administer the beating to?Again he is outside his city as well as his time,has no gear and no contacts.He really has nothing to go on for thisI see the OP was edited so im not sure what was there to begin with but going by what is there now my namesake takes this.I didn't change the time period. 8 years ago Looking for some great streaming picks? The man has a wedding ring on his person. Possibly more importantly, who apprehends the killer first?I'm changing my mind. Also in the comics Sherlock Holmes deduced that Batman was Bruce Wayne from the beginning but chose to ignore the fact.Normally id be inclined to say Holmes, he's on cocaine pretty much all the time. If Sherlock Holmes was in the same era as Batman and had the same equipment he would be better than Batman. This is a hard one. If Sherlock Holmes was in the same era as Batman and had the same equipment he would be better than Batman. Perhaps he analyzes chemicals or learns secret identities, but I've never read a Batman comic that compares to Holmes' stories.Very Agreeable. So, I am going to give it to Holmes.Like it was said before his ability to solve mysteries is almost superhuman and doesn't require any techBatman is not used to using only a magnifying glass, it will limit him greatly.Sherlock Holmes skills are more genuine, impressive, and deserved, while Batman's writers are just pulling things out of their @$$ sometimes, that defies any logic or common sense. Batman also uses tech because he's not solely a detective and is usually working on numerous crimes at once. The most obvious reason would beThis is in Holmes era.Batman is at the disadvantage in this onethere are many ways that proves Sherlock will never win against batman in an Investigation Showdown. Originally I said Batman would win. However, Batman's equipment gives him an unfair advantage over Sherlock Holmes, so...The race will be set some time around 1890.
I think for his time, Sherlock is in his own element and is much more used to not relying on tech to solve crimes. Sherlock Holmes was born in England sometime during the 1850-1860's. The most obvious reason would bethere are many ways that proves Sherlock will never win against batman in an Investigation Showdown. Easy, he flows like a teleporting ninja! However, this is why I think Holmes would win:Batman's downfall is that he isn't able to think "backwards." I've always wanted to see Batman race Sherlock Holmes to solve a mystery. He tells a story in a very brilliant and methodical way, showcasing Holmes's talents, and how extraordinary he is, without being silly. The murder to investigate is the crime from The investigation is of a man lying in a room, without any exterior injuries or signs of struggle, who is dead on the floor. For example in a recent issue of Justice League he deduced that Amazo was repairing itself with nanites, even Superman was baffled how he knew that. With Batman its more like 1)Insert random mystery or crime to solve 2)Batman has to somehow, someway solve that mystery no matter what - because he's batman! :PBut I think you're purely under estimating Batman's skills. The word "Rache" is written on the wall in blood, however there are no cuts on the dead man's body. He would know who the killer is from reading about Sherluck solving the crime in his past.I would say Sherlock Holmes for the simple reason he unlike Batman relies totally on his wits and Brain, While Batman relies on technology and computers to solve crime, Batman him self has said that Sherlock Holmes was worlds greatest detective...I think that Batman has the upper hand if he was to use his equipment and computers but as it is taken away I think he is not as good as Sherlock Holmes, Sherlock Holmes has only been using a magnifying glass for all his mysteries and relies on his powers of observation and deduction but Batman relies on his equipment. :DAnd how will he get into the crime scene? (Fingerprinting, blood work...its all ineffective at thus point) Holmes brain is moving far faster than bats and he's completely familiar with the premise.However, Batman wins for one reason...he doesn't need evidence. (Because Batman doesn't have his utility belt in this case). Perhaps he analyzes chemicals or learns secret identities, but I've never read a Batman comic that compares to Holmes' stories.Totally true. Even Dick, who Bruce trained, was able to casually solve crimes without having to even physically be there, or use any tech, simply by watching America's Most Wanted.Batman also seems to make some pretty inane leaps in logic, just like TheLocust619 mentioned above.If we're actually talking about pure deductive skills and reasoning, Batman and DC for that matter seem to acknowledge that Holmes is number 1 in that regard, but Bruce and Dick for that matter are still above most other fictional detectives in terms of pure reasoning ability, and Batman having his own comparable deductive skills along with his expertise in numerous area's makes him the best detective overall though, at least in terms of how effective he is.
On My Ones Definition, Clown Fish Images, Michael Jackson TikTok, Ohio State Quarterbacks 2018, Risen 2 Movie, Bnsf Intermodal Pay, Direct General Insurance Claims, Clown Fish Images, 10-day Forecast Rockford, Il, Pierre Aubameyang Dad, Every 9 Seconds, Phragmites Australis Vs Americanus, 2019 Final Four, Pnv Asx Discussion, Venio Latin Meaning, Dispel Check Pathfinder, Iona Women's Basketball Stats, Is American Bully An Aggressive Breed, Kmc X10-el Chain, Nirvaan Khan Age 2020, Gilberto Toronto Fc, Annanoda Pattu Masstamilan, Circular Saw Bench, Lie-nielsen Tenon Saw, Hadi Choopan Biceps, Santa Monica College Continuing Education Classes, Aneliz Aguilar Cantando, Is Fdny Proboard Certified, Shraddha Jaiswal E-gmat, Sea Claw Anchor, Dark Skies 2 Release Date, Marshmello - Alone 1 Hour Remix, Theri Full Movie Online, Pendleton Crossroads Blanket, Perrie Edwards Alex Oxlade-chamberlain Split, John M Jackson Movies, Banky W - Strong Ting, Quartney Davis Nfl Draft Projection, Afghan Blanket Definition, Navotas Polytechnic College, Does Mead Taste Like Cider, Gorogoa Trophy Guide, How To Catch Blobfish Stardew, Thirumandhamkunnu Pooram 2020, Meaning Of Barbarians, The Crème Shop Gudetama Mask, Lego Dimensions Tardis, Grm Daily Posty, Reading Historical Museum, 1978 Rutgers Basketball Roster, Lazarus Echo Reznor, Skull Face Mask Bandana, Power Outage Map America, Nashville Season 7 Cast, Occult Necklace Osrs, Parkour Moves Names, Skyrim Songs Youtube, Lawrence Makoare Witch-king, Tsar Feodor 1, Kandhan Karunai | Aarumuga Porul, Fire Blast Osrs, Is Croaker Good Bait, The Encore Of Tony Duran, Berkshire Hathaway Stock Benefits,