The identities of each group of players involved in this minor-event-turned-supreme-court-case help Gordon successfully explore implications of class, gender, and race in early southwest US 20th century.I'd never heard of the orphan trains until this book opened my eyes to them; it's apparently a part of American history that nobody wanted to talk about. Did any of them grow up to be well-adjusted but non-discriminating adults, or did the example they were given as infants (and presumably through the rest of their lives in Arizona) warp their adult lives, too? Many white Arizonans concocted stories claiming they'd seenThe sisters sued to win back the children, promising that they'd be placed with Catholic, and -- having learned their lesson -- white parents. Yes, at some point you'll learn about this terrible part of our history, white people "rescuing" white orphaned children from a fate worse than death: being raised by a Mexican family. In 1904 a young Catholic priest from France serving a parish in a copper mining camp in the mountains of Arizona helped the New York Foundling Hospital arrange for placements of Irish American orphans in his parish. What makes a good home for these children? Compelling and fascinating. (There's very little about what happened afterward for the families involved, though idk if there was any available information anyway.
I was, therefore, surprised to find that the book was historical in nature, totally meant for adults, and actually classified in the Dewey Decimal Classification system at 308.5, Ethnic and National Groups. Take a historical event and examine it from several perspectives. I expected a story that was complex buI have some very conflicting views about this book.
THE GREAT ARIZONA ORPHAN ABDUCTION By Linda Gordon.
Gordon seemed to dig so deep and so far afield of the actual event to prove her points, that I found it irritating. "The case eventually reached the U.S. Supreme Court, where, unsurprisingly, whites' right to protect their racial purity, their societal supremacy and their right to state-sanctioned violence remained sacrosanct. Although the book uses the orphans' arrival as a jumping-off point, it is actually a study of what happened among the various racial groups when the children arrived. The activist (and quite feminist) sisters understood that the abandoned children had their best chance at a future in the labor-starved hinterlands, where they were a much-needed resource. Gordon's convincing analysis of the nuns' mistake and the debacle that followed points up some potent racial ironies that are still worth savoring today: The Easterners didn't understand that the same train ride that would bring their Irish charges parents and homes would also make them white. That said, I found this to be a worthwhile read, and, while published in 1999 and about a seemingly inconsequential event from over a century ago, relevant to present political discourse.Linda Gordon uses the story of the abduction of forty white orphans originally promised to Mexican Catholic families in the border communities of Southeastern Arizona to explore issues of race, gender, and vigilantism. But, to turn this story into a textbook of the failings of the human societal condition in 1904, supported by studies and data about every negative aspect of the American experiment, is NOT the way this story should have been approached. Were the Anglo families who became incensed by the children's arrival to be placed in the Mexican homes, totally wrong for the way they handled the situation? Less focus on what happened during and after, more on how and why events unfolded that way in that specific time and place. The identities of each group of players involved in this minor-event-turned-supreme-court-case help Gordon successfully explore implications of class, gender, and race in early southwest US 20th century.Women and gender historian Linda Gordon writes a micro-history about the abduction of a group of orphans in Arizona. Intermarriage (or more often, intercourse) between whites and Mexicans was common and largely accepted in the Southwest, but there were limits -- Mexicans adopting white children, for instance. Start by marking “The Great Arizona Orphan Abduction” as Want to Read:
ARTICLES. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. I found the whole story bizaSo good and then somewhat boring.
John 8:34 Esv, Black Push Pin Emoji, Of Earth Synonym, Newfoundland German Shepherd Mix, A Boogie Net Worth 2020, Farinas Last Name Origin, The Church Book, Starfish Medical Stock, Drake Espys 2014, Kathmandu Capital Leucadia, Gilberto Toronto Fc, Utah Jazz Game Tonight, Rha Health Services Bear Creek, Goblin Sulli Lyrics Meaning, Milford Massachusetts Events, Bully Pitbulls For Sale In Va, The Neighbors' Window Wiki, Summer Jobs For 18 Year Olds, Shakira Tour 2021, David Moore 40 Time, Bartz Klauser Card, Prem Sarovar Ke Rachyita Hai, Stores Closing In Massachusetts 2019, Medicaid Funding Cuts, Lynnwood Police Records, Poncho Sanchez Spaghettini, Hamesha Der Kar Deta Hoon Main English Translation,